Want to order over the phone?
Call (424) 293-0474
Thank you for being with us!
We will call you back!
Want to order over the phone?
Call (424) 293-0474
08:00 - 17:00
08:00 - 17:00
08:00 - 17:00
00:00 - 17:00
00:00 - 17:00
Best pizza in the area. I travel 40 minutes to pick up some slices once a week. Friendly owner, fresh, handmade food.
MoreGreat pizza...try the buffalo chicken deep dish...yum
Get the grandma pie! Excellent.
Great food nice guy
Good food, nice owner, cute shop
Excellent!
Always great !
Great for a quick slice
Hand down best pizza on Long Island.Friendly staff, great food made to order!Your missing out if you don't try it!
MoreVisiting from out of town and stopped by on our way to Vanderbilt museum and planetarium. Delicious perfect cheese pie! Absolutely perfect crisp yet dense crust and delicious sauce. Family meal deal was a steal with salad garlic knots 2 liter soda and pie for $23. Definitely recommend !!!
MoreGreat Sicilian Pie
Delicious pizza! Got the garlic and tomato slice. Will come again when in centerport!
MoreGreat food, great service. Always my number one spot to go to - owners are amazing too!
MoreBest Sicilian anywhete
Always excellent
They don't answer the phone and close early....
Timothy's Pizzeria quickly became a family favorite as soon as we moved into the neighborhood. We typically go there at least once a week and Michael and his crew are phenomenal!
MoreUsed to always be great...consistant....past few months Not so good and the price is always different....last chance😥
MoreBeen going here for 5+ years. Always a great slice! Best of which in my opinion are Sicilian, grandma, and especially chicken parm slice.
MoreThey take forever to get to your house and very little communication
This place is fantastic. Great owners, great service and great pizza.
Tastes like every long island pizza. Did i i ever tell you about the worst pizza on li? It was great!
MoreThis place is a hole in the wall of Centerport! I had a delicious tomato n basil slice never had it before any where,it was delicious also had a cauliflower parmesan slice to die for if u love cauliflower, I definitely going back to get me a hall pie(sorry no pictures of the slices) but one won't be disappointed.
MoreAwesome pizza!
For a little hole in the wall the pizza is excellent
Only pizza in Centerport